Bassanese's Market Insights: a tale of two markets | BetaShares

Bassanese’s Market Insights: a tale of two markets

BY David Bassanese | 15 April 2015

Although the Australian equity market is traditionally divided up into 11 “GIC” sectors, we can aggregate further into four key broader sectors: resources (energy and materials); cyclicals (industrials, consumer discretionary, and technology); defensives (consumer staples, health care, utilities and telecommunications), and financials (including listed property). Breaking down the market in this way produces some interesting results.


As seen in the table above, by market capitalisation resources, cyclicals, defensives and financials comprise 20%, 12%, 20% and 48% of the market respectively as at end-March 2015.  The overall Australian share market has been grinding out reasonable gains over the past few years, though with notable sector divergences. Indeed, the major factor holding back the market – and contributing to its underperformance compared with global peers – has been the slump in resource sector stocks, which were once the “darling” of the market.

 Price Performance

As seen in the chart below, all sectors excepting resources have been moving higher since mid-2012. Since end-May 2012 to end-March 2015, the S&P/ASX 200 price index has lifted by 45% – or a 13.9% compound annualised rate. Over the same period, financials were the standout rising by 77%, while defensives (typically with attractive yields) also rose by 59%. Yet despite the sluggish economy, it’s notable that even cyclical stocks rose by 44% – or broadly in line with the overall market. By contrast, prices in the resources sector have retreated by 8%.


Earnings Performance

In turn, the weakness in resource stocks has largely reflected the weakness in earnings. As seen in the chart below, resource sector “forward earnings” have been declining since the peak in commodity prices in late 2011, while earnings in all other three sectors have continued to trend higher. Since end-September 2011, resource sector forward earnings have slumped by 49%, while earnings in the defensive and financial sectors have lifted by 22% and 16% respectively. Signs of the sluggish economy, however, are evident by the fact that cyclical sector earnings have eked out only a 4% gain over this period. Overall, market forward earnings have declined by 9% since the peak end-September 2011. One worry for the market, however, is that there are tentative signs of a flattening out in forward earnings among the non-resource sectors since mid-2014.



Another worry for the market is that, at least in outright price-to-forward earnings terms, valuations are at the top end of their ranges for the past decade or so in all major sector groups – including resources. This suggests the market – and all four key sectors – are increasingly reliant on interest rates staying exceptionally low and/or a decent rebound in economic growth and earnings over the coming year.



  1. Bill  |  April 23, 2015

    It appears to me that Australia has become financial flotsam. With the BoJ, the ECB and others being huge players in our foreign exchange markets, as well as our bond market – both being third or fourth most traded in the world – our share market is being driven by short term returns and dividend expectations by speculators. The stark contrast between price performance and earnings performance as you have clearly explained here cannot be sustained. My guess is some black swan event will trigger a correction to valuations, and share prices will fall to match forward- earnings estimates. I moved 100% of my investments overseas in November 2013 and they remain there. After reading yours and other wise heads, like Ross Garnaut’s, investment outlook at the time I have never looked back.

    1. David Bassanese  |  April 24, 2015

      Thanks for your comments Bill. With the decline in the $A since late 2013, plus rising global markets, your offshore returns should have done well. Good luck in your future investments and happy you are still enjoying our ongoing research. Regards David

Leave a Reply